A Wife for Two Rivals Cast and Character Guide: Who's Who in the Mafia Romance

A secret marriage, a fake death, and two powerful men fighting for the same woman set the stage for "A Wife for Two Rivals." Here's a look at the cast bringing this emotional mafia romance to life, from its leading stars to the supporting characters who shape Sophia's journey.

GoodShort's "A Wife for Two Rivals" blends romance, heartbreak, and mafia intrigue into a story about love lost and second chances. Led by Haley Lohrli and Franky Cammarata, the series follows a woman who leaves behind a painful marriage, only to find herself caught between her former husband and the man who helped her build a new life.

About "A Wife for Two Rivals"

Sophia Rossini has spent five years as the invisible wife of James Moretti, the heir to a powerful mafia empire. Believing she has always been nothing more than a stand-in for James's first love, Vicky Spencer, Sophia secretly divorces him after discovering she is pregnant and disappears to Paris to start over.

Years later, James finally finds Sophia, only to discover she has built a new life alongside another man, Alex King. As old feelings resurface and long-buried secrets come to light, the former couple is drawn into a battle over love, forgiveness, and the family they never truly left behind.

Here's a closer look at the “A Wife for Two Rivals” cast bringing the story to life.

Haley Lohrli as Sophia Rossini

Haley Lohrli stars as Sophia Rossini, whose decision to leave her unhappy marriage sets the story in motion. After faking her death and raising her daughter in secret, Sophia must confront the past when James unexpectedly reenters her life.

Based in Los Angeles, Lohrli has been acting since childhood and describes performing as her greatest passion. Alongside acting, she has worked as a writer and director and studied psychology at California State University, Bakersfield.

Lohrli has become a familiar face in vertical dramas, with credits including "Step by Step," "Found My Daddy at the Construction Site," "Twins Hide and Seek After One Night," "My Duplicated Husband," "Breaking News," "Operation Christmas Trap," "I Am the Mafia Girl Boss and He's My Man," "Bring Back My Heart," "Love & Open Marriage," "I'm Her Mother Kneel," "Miss You After Goodbye," "You Divorced a Genius Heiress," "The Arrangement," and "How to Dump a Hockey Star," among many others.

Franky Cammarata as James Moretti

Franky Cammarata plays James Moretti, the powerful mafia heir who realizes too late that he has lost the woman he truly loved. His relentless search for Sophia drives much of the drama after learning she has started a new life with another man.

Before becoming a vertical drama actor, Cammarata built a successful modeling career that began in Atlanta and later brought him to Los Angeles. Signed with Wilhelmina, he worked internationally, including booking an Armani Jeans campaign in Italy before transitioning into acting.

Since entering the vertical drama industry in 2025, Cammarata has appeared in "Kidnapped by the Mafia," "She Finds Redemption in His Love," "Trapped and Redeemed by His Love," "This Time I Choose Mr. Mafia," "Bound by Blood: The Mafia King's Sweetheart," "Cases Closed: The Legal Queen Returns," "Found My Daddy at the Construction Site," "Found a Homeless Genius to Save My Company," "Boss, Your Ex-Con Bride Is Back," "The Girl They Left Behind," "Assemble My Avenging Billionaires," "Dominate Me Please, Mafia King," "Oops I Married My Daughter's Daddy," and "I Stand Where Love Ends."

Ashley BeLoat as Vicky Spencer

Ashley BeLoat portrays Vicky Spencer, James's former girlfriend whose return becomes the catalyst for Sophia's heartbreaking decision to leave. (IMDb)

A Los Angeles-based actress, model, and nurse, BeLoat has become well known among vertical drama audiences for playing both memorable villains and increasingly complex leading characters. She has collaborated with several short-form drama platforms and has earned a reputation for her versatility across romance, revenge, and family dramas.

Her growing list of credits includes "Love Me Again, Mama," "A Mistake at Sea: The Evil Bride Crossed the Billionaire Madam," "Mafia Daddy Next Door," "The Wedding That Never Was," "What Exactly Lies in the Dance Studio," "Cases Closed: The Legal Queen Returns," "The Forbidden Love with the Young CEO," "My Miracle Luna," "Mother Nature and the Doomsday Prepper," "The Queen Strikes Back with Three Tycoons," "Fake It Till You Love Me," "Recipe for Faking a Marriage," and "From Contract Lover to the Billionaire's Bride."

Aidan Browne as Alex King

Aidan Browne plays Alex King, the man Sophia builds a new life with after leaving James. When James finally tracks her down, Alex becomes his romantic rival as both men fight for Sophia's heart.

Born and raised in Los Angeles, Browne studied at the University of Southern California's School of Cinematic Arts while simultaneously working behind the scenes as a producer, assistant director, executive producer, and director.

His producing work includes "Wing and a Prayer" and "The Portrait," and he has also produced music videos for artists including Johnny Orlando and The Driver Era.

Alongside his filmmaking career, Browne has appeared in numerous vertical dramas, including "One Night Flame Between Me and Mr. Right," "Mr. Big, the Baby Is Not Yours," "Runaway Baby, Bound by a String," "The Breaking Point of Love," "Falling for the Wrong Me," "Perfect Landing Into Your Arms," "The Real vs. the Fake Heiress," "Make My Mom Bloom Again," "My Call Boy Billionaire Daddy," "Flashback Fiancée: Have We Met?," "Assassin's Apprentice: Falling for the Target," and "Murdered My Father, Captured My Heart."

Sophie Lafleche as Amber Rossini

Sophie Lafleche plays Amber Rossini, Sophia's daughter, whom she secretly raises after leaving James. As Amber grows up away from the mafia world, James remains unaware that she is his child, adding another emotional layer to the story.

Based in Los Angeles, Lafleche is a young actress known for her natural screen presence and expressive performances. She has trained in on-camera acting and improv with Margie Haber Studio and has also studied with acting coaches Zak Barnett and Jesse Posey.

Despite her young age, Lafleche has already appeared in several vertical dramas, including "Blood Doesn't Make You Family," "Oops I Married My Daughter's Daddy," "Mommy Hold on I Brought Daddy to Save You," "Love Under Fire," "I Stand Where Love Ends," "My New Daddy Is a Five-Star General," and "Baby Daddy That's Not Your Kid!" She has also built experience through a number of short films and commercial projects.

A Story of Love, Loss, and Second Chances

With a cast that blends rising vertical drama stars and familiar faces, "A Wife for Two Rivals" combines romance, family secrets, and mafia intrigue into an emotional story about choosing between the past and the future.

Whether viewers are drawn to Sophia's journey of self-discovery, James's desperate fight to win her back, or Alex's place in her new life, the series offers plenty of twists for fans of relationship-driven vertical dramas.